A name with possibilities.

Five matching observations do not settle all six cards

Six distinct cards are labelled A through F, each bearing exactly one integer. The claim is that every one of these six integers is even. Supplied observations show A has two, B four, C six, D eight and E ten. F has not been inspected. Treat the observations as exact within this fictional exercise. There is no sampling model or rule that determines the value on F from the other cards.

Siverita.com
Five observed cards and one unknown in the Siverita coverage worksheetClaim: all six cards bear even integersA: 2 · B: 4 · C: 6 · D: 8 · E: 10F: unknownCoverage: 5 of 6 · claim unresolvedNo probability model is supplied

01

Record the narrower statement that is supported

All five observed integers are even, so the observations support the statement that the inspected cards A through E bear even integers. They do not settle the claim about all six because F remains unknown. Record coverage as five of six cards, with F explicitly listed as unobserved. Do not convert five matching observations into a probability that F is even; the exercise supplies no distribution from which such a probability could be calculated. The assessment is unresolved for the full claim, not contradicted and not established by the five observations alone.

An odd value is a counterexample in the Siverita coverage worksheetAlternative continuation 1F is revealed as 99 is odd: F is a counterexampleThe all-six claim is contradictedOne in-scope counterexample is sufficient

02

Compare two alternative reveals of the missing card

In one hypothetical continuation, F is revealed to contain nine. Nine is odd, so F is a counterexample and the claim that all six integers are even is contradicted. In a separate continuation from the same starting record, F contains twelve. Now all six specified cards have been inspected and each bears an even integer, so the finite claim is supported under the exercise’s accepted observations. These continuations are alternatives, not two observations of the same unchanged card. Keep them in separate records so the example does not create an artificial conflict.

An even value completes this finite check in the Siverita coverage worksheetAlternative continuation 2F is revealed as 12All six inspected values are evenFinite claim supported: A through FThis says nothing about other cards

03

Save a claim-and-coverage record

The reusable template contains the exact claim, target items, observation for each item, missing items, accepted assumptions and the resulting assessment with its reason. For the initial record, write five even observations, one unknown and unresolved. For the nine continuation, identify F as the counterexample. For the twelve continuation, record complete coverage of this six-card set. None of these results establishes a claim about cards outside A through F. If a card’s value later changes, the earlier record describes its earlier state; preserve that context instead of treating an old assessment as timeless.

siverita.com

Explore Siverita

Held for potential development. Acquisition inquiries may be considered.

Domain options ↗